| Subscribe via RSS

Toxic diesel fumes result in severe health risks

April 6th, 2010 | No Comments | Posted in Health and Safety

The major cause of air pollution is exhaust from vehicles, especially the particulate matter (PM) from diesel engines. Unlike many toxic substances, there is no safe level of PM concentration and no means of mitigation except to remove the source.

There are 12 thousand people living within a 300 metre zone of influence of toxic air in the proposed Kettle Island Corridor. The Montfort Hospital, Montfort Long Term Care Facility, and Our Lady of Mount Carmel School are directly adjacent to The Aviation Parkway. Despite the very obvious evidence to the contrary the consultants for the bridge study have determined that the air quality impact on the Kettle Island Corridor is ZERO.

The following is a list of key conclusions of other studies around air pollution and health effects near high traffic-areas.

  • Air pollution from busy roads linked to shorter life spans for nearby residents
  • Truck traffic linked to childhood asthma hospitalization
  • Pregnant women who live near high traffic areas more likely to have premature and low birth weight babies
  • Traffic-related air pollution associated with respiratory symptoms in two year old children
  • People who live near freeways exposed to 25 times more particle pollution
  • Asthma more common for children living near freeways.
  • Children living near busy roads more likely to develop cancer (particularly high risk for leukemia)
  • Most traffic related deaths are due to air pollution, not traffic accidents,
  • Emissions from motor vehicles dominate cancer risk
  • Cancer risk higher near major sources of air pollution, including highways
  • A school’s proximity to freeways associated with asthma prevalence
  • Lung function reduction among children more likely if living near truck traffic
  • Asthma symptoms caused by truck exhaust
  • Exposure to carcinogenic benzene (associated with aplastic anemia and leukemia) higher for children living near high traffic areas

For more information on these studies see http://www.sdearthtimes.com/et0603/et0603s21.html

You are also encouraged to refer to a study from the 13th Annual University of California Transportation Research Conference February 16, 2007, which looks at the negative impacts of trucks in communities:  http://www.its.ucla.edu/uctc/PowerPoints/Houston_UCLA.pdf

A further study has shown that babies’ DNA can be damaged even before they are born if their mothers breathe polluted air during pregnancy. This type of damage to the chromosomes makes people more susceptible to cancer. For more information see http://ecomall.com/greenshopping/babyair.htm

Send your concerns to info@ncrcrossings.ca

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Air quality a deadly concern

February 7th, 2009 | No Comments | Posted in Health and Safety, Project Critique

Contributed by Judy Lishman:
—————
The consultant has said that there would be no impact on air quality in the Kettle Island corridor, the most heavily populated corridor studied. He is wrong.

The adverse health effects of diesel exhaust fumes are well documented. Studies by the American Lung Association indicate that 70-80% of the cancer risk from air pollution is due to particulate matter emissions from diesel engines.

According to Environment Canada, fine particulate matter is considered to be toxic as defined in the Canadian Environmental Protection Act, 1999.

Increased roadway pollution produced by diesel fuel in vehicles is leading to a cascade of conditions that could result in heart attack or stroke and premature death researchers noted in a report to the American Heart Association.

The Canadian Medical Association states that “the link between exposure to diesel exhaust and asthma has been borne out in epidemiological studies indicating that children living along major trucking routes are at increased risk of asthma and allergic symptoms and of having respiratory dysfunction.

The Ontario Government through its “Strategic Options To Address The Fine Particulate Issue In Ontario” recognizes the serious issue of diesel exhaust. “Recent scientific studies have statistically linked atmospheric fine particulate matter arising from diesel exhaust with harmful human health effects such as cancer, the exacerbation of asthma, respiratory disease, heart disease and chronic obstructive lung disease. Unlike the situation with many other toxic substances, for fine particulate matter there is no known threshold concentration below which exposures are deemed safe. Therefore, even at very low levels of ambient particulate matter, susceptible individuals including the elderly, children and people with pre-existing respiratory or cardiovascular disease may respond adversely.”

There are 12000 people in the Kettle Island corridor who live within the zone of influence of the toxic emissions of diesel trucks. It is not only a possibility but a certainty that a percentage of them will get cancer, heart disease, lung disease and die prematurely as a result of diesel emissions if the bridge is built at Kettle Island.

According to Ontario’s strategy, measures need to be introduced to attain desirable particulate matter levels in the province. Since cities are the place where most of Ontario’s population resides, reduction of particulate matter effects in cities is crucial.

The consultant’s answer is that mitigation measures will be studied in phase 2. There are no mitigation measures available other than removing trucks from populated areas.

The trucks must be directed to a corridor remote from people so that diesel exhaust emissions can be adequately attenuated.

The recommendation by the consultant to locate a new bridge in the Kettle Island corridor must be rejected in order to protect the health and lives of the people who live there.
—————

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Tags:

Ontario Ministry of the Environment must get involved

February 7th, 2009 | No Comments | Posted in Health and Safety

Contributed by Judy Lishman:
—————
The Ontario Ministry of the Environment must become actively involved in The Interprovincial Crossings Study in order to provide protection to Ontario citizens.

The Terms of Reference of the study state that it is a harmonized study with the federal government and the two provinces as the proponents and funding partners. The most stringent of their environmental legislation is to apply.

In order to avoid overlapping jurisdictions, the federal Environmental Act only applies to the natural environment not to the human environment. The human environment is afforded protection by the provincial Environmental Acts.

At this point in the bridge study, Ontario residents are left with no protection because the Ontario Ministry of the Environment is not involved in the study. At the outset, they declined to participate in approving the Terms of Reference because they said it wasn’t clear if Ontario was a proponent. Since Ontario has been named a proponent by the NCC, the MTO is actively participating in the study, Ontario is being asked their opinion on the study’s recommendation and is helping to pay for it, it is clear that the MOE must be involved at every stage of this study. The Environmental Assessment Legislation was enacted to protect the citizens of Ontario in exactly these circumstances.

If a bridge is built at Kettle Island thousands of Ontario citizens will be exposed daily to health and safety hazards. We need protection from our government.
—————

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Trucks and schools don’t mix

January 26th, 2009 | 2 Comments | Posted in Health and Safety

A great contribution to the website from Alice, a concerned citizen:

The Kettle Island corridor is the most heavily populated corridor with 11 or more schools and colleges surrounding the Aviation Parkway, the closest school less than a block away. Take a look at Kettle Island truck route – a closer look for a detailed map of the corridor, showing these schools and other impacted institutions.

From: 13th Annual University of California Transportation Research Conference February 16, 2007

  • Freeways’ tainted air harms children’s lungs, experts say
  • Lifelong damage is found in 13-year study of 3,600 Southland youngsters living within 500 yards of a highway. The Los Angeles Times, 1/26/07
  • Residential proximity within 200 meters of a major roadway was strongly associated with childhood asthma and wheeze
  • Risks were larger within 75 meters of a major roadway
  • Heavy Duty Diesel Trucks (HDDT) emit high levels of particulate matter (PM) and oxides of nitrogen (NOX), and a complex mixture of gaseous air pollutants
  • 41 of these gaseous and/or particle-associated pollutants are listed in California as toxic air contaminants
  • Diesel exhaust PM has been associated with approximately 70 percent of known potential cancer risk from air toxics in Southern California (SCAQMD, 1999)
  • Over 70 percent of California’s Diesel PM pollution is from the goods movement sector, and over 70 percent of these emissions were from Heavy Duty Diesel Trucks (CARB, 2006)
  • Ultrafine particles (< 0.1 μm) can penetrate cell walls and the blood-brain and can be easily absorbed into vital organs

The full presentation can be read at: http://www.its.ucla.edu/uctc/PowerPoints/Houston_UCLA.pdf

Of course based on the criteria used by the committee none of this is as important as the needs of the trucks.

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Tags:

Montfort Hospital: Facts and figures

Some facts and figures about the Montfort Hospital, which will be negatively impacted by the Kettle Island bridge.

On the expansion of Montfort:

  • In 2006, the government announced a $283 million investment to expand the Montfort hospital. This will increase the size of the hospital by 125% and will add 450,000 square feet of new space.
  • Furthermore, The hospital has invested $21 million in new equipment, and will be investing an additional $40 million, bringing the total to $61 million apart from the initial cost of $283 million.
  • At the end of the construction and renovations, Montfort will have 289 beds available for acute care, plus 128 beds for long term care (total: 417 beds).

On services available at the end of the construction:

  • Visits at the emergency will increase by 73%, and will accommodate more than 55,000 visits per year
  • Intensive care unit will double in size
  • Surgery rooms will rise from 7 to 11, and cases of surgery will increase from 6,090 to 9,730 a year
  • 84% increase in the number of visits due to exams, medical orders, etc. for a total of 1 million visits per year
  • The number of hospital employees will rise from 950 to 1,500

On training:

  • Montfort will accommodate 500 students in 36 disciplines related to health care, including 260 students in medicine
  • Montfort also has a key partnership with Ottawa University and is the hospital offering the most support in terms of practical experience for students in medicine

On women and children’s health:

  • Increase in the number of deliveries from 1,220 to 2,700 per year.
  • This year the Montfort will host 2,800 deliveries
  • 18 single rooms for labour, birth, recovery and post-partum, plus 11 traditional rooms, whereas previously there were 6 labour beds and a post partum unit of 14 beds.
  • Montfort will also provide a new model for providing health services to women in partnership with the community

Note that the new Montfort will include a new Health Centre for National Defence in the National Capital region, in association with DND. A new team of specialists will integrate the hospital to provide specialized care to the military.

How does the Montfort Hospital feel about the Kettle Island bridge and the impact on its ability to care for its patients? Check out the videos below for coverage of the Montfort press conference on the topic:

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Tags:

Not on my commuting route

December 24th, 2008 | 2 Comments | Posted in Health and Safety, News and Commentary

Concern around increased commuting time, the main reason eastern Ottawa favours Kettle Island over other alternatives, has been recently raised by the Blackburn Community Association (Get on with the bridge, Ottawa Citizen, Dec. 22). The poor chaps want to save their 5 minutes per day to get to work.

Never mind that the Kettle Island corridor passes through 7 km of established residential areas, and would spew poisonous diesel fumes from over 1700 trucks per day into the lungs of 100K residents, families, and children living in the immediate vicinity of the corridor.  And never mind that the Gatineau Airport corridor, a much more preferable option in my opinion, would pass through 0 km of established residential areas.

The fight against the Kettle Island bridge is founded upon protecting health, safety, and quality of life within our communities.  I would argue that this is a much more noble and worthy fight than one based on “not on my commuting route”.

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

News clip from the future – Oct 31, 2014

December 15th, 2008 | No Comments | Posted in Health and Safety, News and Commentary

A prophetic submission by a concerned citizen.   Will we soon be reading about pedestrian deaths caused by heavy truck traffic on the Aviation Parkway?  Quite possibly.
_________

Cognitive Scientists have developed an innovative computer program called “THINK”, an acronym for Transform History Into New Knowledge.

THINK enables researchers to analyse the  logic of historical documents, such as newspaper articles, by redrafting them to assigned dates in the future. In the example below, an Ottawa Citizen article from October 31, 2008 has been run through the THINK algorithm, generating an article for October 31, 2014.

Pedestrian’s death sparks renewed fight to reroute truck traffic from downtown
Published: Friday, October 31, 2014

Ottawa – An elderly woman has become the latest victim of heavy truck traffic on downtown streets after she was knocked down Friday morning and died later in hospital.

Police said the 86-year-old walked in front of a dump truck while it was stopped within the congested Montreal Road intersection with the Aviation Parkway just after 11 a.m.

Vehicles may have blocked the crosswalk, forcing her to walk in front of the dump truck, Const. Alain Boucher said.

As the traffic ahead began to clear, the driver moved his southbound truck through the intersection and knocked the woman down.

This latest fatality has angry Ottawa residents demanding that the federal transportation minister act quickly to take large trucks out of their neighbourhood.

The city councillor for the area, Jacques Legendre, said this death underlines the urgent need to close the Kettle Island bridge across the Ottawa River to heavy truck traffic.

Theresa Romanaro, an employee at a local restaurant, said she was walking to work when the woman was struck.

“She went right underneath,” she said.

Her co-worker ran into an apartment building nearby to call 911, and when he returned, a bystander was trying to revive the woman.

She had a big gash on her forehead, Ms. Romanaro said. “It was pretty nasty, I’ve still got the chills from it.”

Paramedics performed CPR on the woman before taking her to hospital, where she died. Her name is being withheld until police notify next of kin.

The driver of the Gervais Cartage truck, who appeared badly shaken, was questioned by police then left without talking to reporters.

Police closed Montreal Road between St. Laurent Blvd. and the Aviation Parkway during their investigation. The road was re-opened at about 3:20 p.m.

Her death is only the latest of several, residents say.

“A ten-year-old boy was struck and killed last year while trying to cross the busy truck route on his way home from school,” said Peter Wilson, a concerned resident.

“Following protests by the community, we received assurances that a solution would be found. Well, we are still waiting for a solution,” he said.

About 1,500 trucks travel through the neighbourhood each day, going to or from the Kettle Island Bridge. They are mixing with an increasing number of residents – some of whom are moving into new condominiums – tourists and business people, who travel along Montreal Road, the Aviation Parkway, Hemlock Rd., St. Laurent Blvd. as well as many other residential streets that were never designed for heavy truck traffic.

Mr. Wilson said Friday’s accident dramatically showed the city’s dysfunctional traffic patterns that bring heavy trucks within a few minutes’ walk of the National Aviation Museum, the RCMP Musical Ride, the Montfort Hospital, and through a busy pedestrian neighbourhood.

“It’s insane that we have this heavy truck traffic downtown. It is just a nightmare waiting to happen,” said Mr. Wilson, noting that a heavy truck carrying a dangerous load “could be a total disaster” in a collision downtown.

The Aviation Parkway was never supposed to be a heavy-truck corridor, but, despite assurances when it was built that it would not be used for that purpose, the Parkway was turned into an interprovincial truck route two years ago, when the half-billion dollar Kettle Island Bridge was completed, a residents’ group said in a statement.

There have been several fatal and near fatal incidents in the neighbourhoods along the route since it was built.

In July 2013, a 65-year-old Montreal woman was killed when her car collided with a tractor trailer at the route’s intersection with Ogilvie Road.

The previous September, a man was killed after being run over by a tractor trailer near his home in the La Cité College area.

“It’s happened a lot on this street,” said Ms. Romanaro. “And there are more and more trucks.”

Pedestrians from the nearby Montfort Hospital are often involved in accidents and close calls, said an area man who goes only by his street name, Dusty.

“There have been incidents where people have got pinned under trucks or bounced off them,” he said.

Mr. Wilson said Ottawa is the only national capital that allows its downtown to be used as a truck route. He says the only solution is to close the Kettle Island bridge to trucks, but that the federal government is unlikely to do that after having spent hundreds of millions of dollars in recent years only to create the problem in the first place.

Mr. Wilson and several of his Ottawa colleagues have always opposed the Kettle Island Bridge because it goes through the urban area of Ottawa. They argued for a route from the Canotek Industrial Park to the Gatineau Airport, several kilometres to the east.

“Why do trucks have more rights than pedestrians and the people who live in this community?” asked Mr. Wilson.

“Minister Baird took credit for stopping a bridge in the west end. If he has that kind of clout, then surely he can put an end to this appalling situation now. We want to know what he is going to do, and when.”

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Dowtown vigil for pedestrians injured or killed by trucks downtown

November 13th, 2008 | 1 Comment | Posted in Health and Safety, News and Commentary

A few excerpts from the coverage of an event to commemorate pedestrians injured or killed by truck traffic downtown:

Ottawa Citizen:

Sheila Moore clutched her homemade sign and shivered.

The Ottawa woman was among about 30 people who gathered on the corner of King Edward Avenue and Rideau Street last night to remember people killed or injured by vehicles in this heavily-congested area. The protesters, many of whom were Lowertown residents, carried signs saying, “Our community is not an off ramp” and “No more dead pedestrians.”

Angela Rickman, president of the Lowertown Community Association, said she hoped the vigil would put a human face on the situation, which she says has been a problem for decades.

“This is a recipe for disaster,” she told the crowd. “No community should have to live with this.”

Metro Ottawa:

“Trucks need to be in a location where it can be linked to a future ring road,” said Jane Brammer, chair of the Community Action for Reasonable Analyses and Decision. “They should not be in neighbourhoods, on the front steps of hospitals or on people’s back steps or front doors.”

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Montfort Hospital fights proposed Kettle Island bridge

November 6th, 2008 | 1 Comment | Posted in Health and Safety, News and Commentary

At a press conference on Nov. 5th, the the Montfort Hospital formally and publicly spoke out against the Kettle Island corridor.

As covered by CBC News:

Dr. Bernard Leduc, chief of staff at Montfort Hospital, said Wednesday at a news conference that he wants the National Capital Commission to consider the hospital’s concerns that a bridge at Kettle Island in the east end would result in:

  • Traffic jams that inhibit access to the hospital by ambulances, patients and staff.
  • Vibrations that could affect sensitive equipment such as MRIs.
  • Noise that could hamper patients’ recovery.

“When you’re sick or when you just delivered [a baby], tranquility and peace is something that’s quite important for you in order to help you get well and recuperate better,” Leduc said.

Click here to view full the article.

In a follow-up article, Steve Taylor, the project manager for this study, stated the following:

“We have talked with the hospital before and we have heard their concerns. It isn’t anything that we weren’t aware of,” he said.  “Based on other roadway projects of a similar scope and magnitude, I’m not expecting it to be a show-stopper issue.”

Click here to view that article.

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Tags: ,

Re: “A Nightmare” Oct. 31, 2008

A great letter, unfortunately not published by the Citizen:
————–
Re: “A Nightmare” Oct. 31, 2008

The tragic death of yet another pedestrian along the Rideau/King Edward corridor highlights once again the need for governments to develop a permanent and sensible solution to the travesty of heavy trucking passing though the downtown core and existing residential communities.

The problem was created by short-sighted planning in the 1960s and 1970s. Let’s not blame residents of Vanier and New Edinburgh who fought valiantly, and ultimately successfully, not to have the problem merely shifted to their residential communities.

Incredibly, short-sighted planning views have once again come to the fore, in the guise of the consultants’ recommendation of Kettle Island as the preferred corridor for a new interprovincial crossing. This recommendation will not stop the carnage downtown. Under the proposed plan, the number of trucks along the Rideau/King Edward corridor in 2031 will be the same as today.

What’s more, a new killing zone will be opened up. Is a life lost at Montreal Rd. and Aviation worth any less than one lost at Cumberland and Rideau?

The Kettle Island route represents the worst possible outcome for all residents of Ottawa. It won’t solve the truck problem. It will attract the most automobile commuter traffic from Gatineau—clogging routes already overloaded with commuters and leaving Ottawa taxpayers footing the bill for increased road construction and maintenance costs. It will pose a serious threat to the Montfort Hospital. It will destroy a scenic parkway and green space. It will do nothing to encourage economic development. It will divide and degrade existing residential communities along the entire route, which is the longest possible path between Hwy 50 and Hwy174.

Bravo to Georges Bédard for opposing the Kettle Island Route and supporting a new bridge where it belongs—in a commercial/industrial area farther removed from the downtown core.

John Forsey
President, Manor Park Community Association
————–

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Heavy truck traffic causes tragic death downtown

November 1st, 2008 | 2 Comments | Posted in Health and Safety, News and Commentary

‘A nightmare’ – Pedestrian’s death sparks renewed fight to reroute truck traffic from downtown

An elderly woman has become the latest victim of heavy truck traffic on downtown streets after she was knocked down Friday morning and died later in hospital.

Click here for the full article, published in the Ottawa Citizen on Oct. 31.

Opponents of the Kettle Island crossing agree that the truck situation at King Edward and Rideau St. is deplorable, but the solution is not to transfer the problem to other highly populated areas such as the intersection of Montreal Rd. and Aviation Parkway – site of a hospital, high rise, pedestrians and bikers. The point is that truck routes should not run through areas where there are a lot of people.  Period.

You are encouraged to write to the Ottawa Citizen in response to this article to reinforce the point that trucks and people don’t mix.

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

500 litres of Diesel Fuel Spills from Ruptured Truck in East End

September 28th, 2008 | No Comments | Posted in Health and Safety, News and Commentary

Ironically, on the very day that consultants from ROCHE-NCE promised an angry mob at Lansdowne that a new truck highway would be “100% safe”, an eighteen wheeler carrying diesel fuel collided with a van at Boundary Rd. The truck lost control and careened into the ditch, rupturing its fuel tanks and spilling more than 500 litres of toxic diesel fuel. A fire service haz-mat team and clean up crew was called in to contain the spill. The Ministry of the Environment is now investigating the accident.

Source: Metro News, Sept 26, 2008.  Click here for the full article.

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Montfort Hospital – How important is it?

September 19th, 2008 | 3 Comments | Posted in Health and Safety, Project Critique

There is a very high degree of likelihood that the MRI machines at the Montfort Hospital would be seriously impacted by the proximity of the proposed Kettle Island trucking route, which would pass within just a few metres of the hospital walls.

From an article on the subject:

Additionally, many MRIs are highly sensitive to vibration. Disruptive or crippling vibrations can be transmitted through the ground from cars, trucks and trains, sometimes from distances over 1,000 feet away. Similarly, vibrations from pumps, fans or motors that are commonly used throughout buildings can be transmitted across a building’s structural frame. Regardless of the origin, vibrations can impair an MRI’s image quality, particularly for many of the latest magnet systems, including 3.0 Tesla models and new high-field open MRIs. At the extreme end, harmonic or high-amplitude vibrations can cause quenches, running the risk of permanently crippling a $1 million magnet.

Click here for the complete article.

The good news is that the consultants have recognized this and have created a sub-factor specific to the MRI impacts at Montfort. The bad news is that this factor counts for only 0.09% (less than 1/1000) of the total score, ranking it tied for 84th place of the 91 factors considered.

The rest of the bad news is that there are no other factors that directly consider the negative impacts on the hospital, such as traffic congestion hindering ambulance access, costs of modifying access routes to the hospital, or disruption to patients and their healing process resulting from traffic noise and poor air quality.

Given the state of our current health care system and the importance of Montfort Hospital to the community, this doesn’t seem quite right.

What can you do about this? Post your comments and feedback on this website for others to see. Attend the Final Public Consultation to express your concerns and spread the word to encourage others to attend. Contact your local federal, provincial and city representatives who have been elected to act in your best interests.

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Tags:

Diesel Fuel Health Issues

September 18th, 2008 | 4 Comments | Posted in Health and Safety, Project Critique

The proposed Kettle Island corridor will be a major trucking route that passes through many established communities. Trucks burn diesel fuel, which has particularly hazardous health effects on people. According to the American Lung Association:

  • Diesel exhaust is a mixture containing over 450 different components, including vapors and fine particles. Over 40 chemicals in diesel exhaust are considered toxic air contaminants by the State of California. Exposure to this mixture may result in cancer, exacerbation of asthma, and other health problems.
  • The health risk from diesel exposure is greatest for children, the elderly, people who have respiratory problems or who smoke, people who regularly strenuously exercise in diesel-polluted areas, and people who work or live near diesel exhaust sources.
  • Studies have shown that the proximity of a child’s residence to major roads is linked to hospital admissions for asthma, and there is a positive relationship between school proximity to freeways and asthma occurrence.

Click here for the full article.

To what extent were facts like these considered by the consultants in their recommendation of the Kettle Island corridor as the preferred location? How much emphasis did they put on the negative health impacts on the people and their children living in the vicinity of the corridor?

Very little.

What can you do about this? Post your comments and feedback on this website for others to see. Attend the Final Public Consultation to express your concerns and spread the word to encourage others to attend. Contact your local federal, provincial and city representatives who have been elected to act in your best interests.

Share on Facebook Share on Facebook

Tags: ,
  • E-mail News Alerts

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

     

  • Polls

    I trust the NCC to do what's best for the National Capital Region

    View Results

    Loading ... Loading ...
  • Who we are.

    This blog was started by Ottawa residents concerned about the selection methodology for a new bridge and inter-provincial truck highway. Our research has led us to believe that Kettle Island is a bad choice for our region, yet we represent no particular group or neighbourhood. Anyone is invited and encouraged to participate in our blog.
     
    Our goal is to reach 100,000 unique visitors in 12 months. Let the politicians know that you care about this issue. Please add us to your social network, website or blog. Post your comments or subscribe to email alerts today!
?>